Who leads the installation work?

Owner Mike Garofalo directs projects, sometimes with crew member Tom. Multiple reviews name him specifically.

Do you clean up during and after work?

Yes; reviewers consistently note the crew cleans daily and leaves jobsites spotless.

How long has the company been operating?

The business states over 25 years in operation on their website.

American Windows & Siding

Updated 2026-08-26 · 7,286 reviewed · 1,143 listed · Scored from 13 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.1(13) 60 low data composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified

Gutters & Siding

Service: Gutters & Siding
Reviews: 13

What recent reviews say

Mostly five-star praise for Mike Garofalo's installation work and clean jobsites. One recent review called a $15,000 storm-door quote excessive. Limited recent reviews.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Recent shift: One month ago, a customer reported receiving a $15,000 quote for a storm door plus $8,000 labor; most prior reviews (3-5 years old) praise the company highly.

Praised for

Mike Garofalo's professionalism and expertise
Quality window and door installations
Daily jobsite cleanup
Responsive and detail-oriented service

Watch-outs

Extreme pricing (recent $15k storm-door quote)
Rudeness and unprofessionalism (old reviews)

skilled-workmanshipresponsive-communicationclean-jobsitepunctualoverpriced

Best for: Homeowners replacing windows and exterior doors

Think twice if: Those watching costs; one recent door quote was $15,000 plus labor.

Strengths

Owner Mike Garofalo with deep expertise
Spotless jobsites daily
Skilled window and door installation
25+ years in business

Worth knowing

Owner Mike Garofalo directs installations
Crew cleans jobsite daily
Mezzo windows from Alside used
Replaced defective window from shipment
Services: windows, doors, siding, gutters, roofing

What reviews say by service

Gutters & Siding: Satisfied with gutter and siding installation; planning to hire again for gutters.

How it compares

Rated 4.1 against a 4.76 average across the 415 gutters & siding businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 66% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Our Rubric

Star rating 67

Review volume 50

Review recency 100

Review sentiment 52

Profile completeness 50

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

Common questions

Who leads the installation work?: Owner Mike Garofalo directs projects, sometimes with crew member Tom. Multiple reviews name him specifically.
Do you clean up during and after work?: Yes; reviewers consistently note the crew cleans daily and leaves jobsites spotless.
How long has the company been operating?: The business states over 25 years in operation on their website.

Request a quote

Similar roofing contractors nearby

Spinelli Exteriors llc - CT GAF roofing, windows, siding, Provia doors, and Gutters

5.0(99)✓ Google-verified

Quality work with exceptional cleanliness and fair pricing appear consistently in every recent review. Projects typically complete in a single day. Crew members remove all nails and debris from jobsites. Owner Dave responds quickly to questions and actively skips lengthy sales pitches. Roof replacement and repair, gutter installation, and window work are the main services. Owner Dave has operated for 20+ years and holds GAF roofing contractor certification. His crew handles complex jobs efficiently, including historic-home installations and 19-window retrofits. Quotes run substantially lower than competing bids.

Gutters & SidingRoof RepairRoof Inspection & Insurance Claims

View profile

Artisan RoofWorks

5.0(129)✓ Google-verified

All 129 reviews give five stars, consistently praising speed, cleanliness, and pricing. A typical roof replacement completes in one day, with crews removing all debris. Diego and his team communicate throughout projects, answer phones promptly, and follow up after completion. The feedback pattern shows reliable execution. Roof replacements and gutter installations are their main work. Dominik and other crew members handle installations while Diego manages customer relationships. The website states they are licensed and insured, operate since 2007, and serve eight towns around East Hampton including Portland, Middletown, and Guilford. They offer free inspections and emergency services.

Flat & Commercial RoofingRoof Inspection & Insurance ClaimsGutters & Siding

View profile