Cruz Roofing and Siding vs A Plus Exterior LLC: gutters & siding compared
Cruz Roofing and Siding and A Plus Exterior LLC are both genuine options for gutters and siding work in Connecticut, with strong review histories and overlapping service areas. This comparison uses our methodology to weigh the factors that actually matter for a gutters-and-siding job: who handles insurance paperwork, who carries manufacturer certifications, and who turns fixes around fastest.
The differences that matter
- Insurance claim handling. Cruz manages the full insurance claims process from inspection to approval, while A Plus quotes promptly and absorbs surprises like hidden rot without describing formal claims work.
- Manufacturer certification. A Plus is a Platinum Certified Owens Corning contractor and HAAG certified for roof inspections, credentials that don't appear in Cruz's profile.
- Track record on Google. Cruz has logged more reviews at a slightly higher composite score (206 reviews, 92.7) than A Plus (154 reviews, 91.6), though both average 4.9 stars.
- Debris and site cleanup. A Plus reviewers call out magnetic nail sweeps and lift equipment for tear-off jobs, while Cruz's cleanup praise centers on leaving no nails behind after siding and roof work.
- Turnaround on fixes. A Plus reviewers cite a gutter color mix-up corrected within 24 hours and same-day emergency leak response, while Cruz is praised for fast touch-ups and emergency repairs without a specific timeframe given.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: 4.9 (206 reviews)
- A Plus Exterior LLC: 4.9 (154 reviews)
- Services
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: flat roofing commercial, roof repair, 24 7 emergency roofing, metal roofing
- A Plus Exterior LLC: gutter services, roof inspection insurance, flat roofing commercial, roof repair
- Best for
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: Storm-damage siding/gutter jobs needing insurance paperwork handled start to finish
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Owens Corning-brand installs and quick, inspection-grade fixes
- Service area emphasis
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: Westport, Fairfield, Shelton, Trumbull
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Milford
- Specialties
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: Complex rooflines, multi-phase remodels, full insurance claims handling
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Owens Corning certified installs, HAAG inspections, debris-heavy tear-offs
- Verification
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: Google-verified
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Cruz Roofing and Siding: 93
- A Plus Exterior LLC: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Cruz Roofing and Siding
From the first conversation through project completion, this team earns praise for turning up on time, listening to what matters to each customer, and walking away with the details done right. David Cruz and his crew handle complex rooflines and siding transformations with visible pride, manage insurance paperwork end-to-end, and follow up on aftercare without argument. Crews arrive early, work late into summer evenings, leave no nails behind, and respond quickly to touch-ups. Reviewers across Westport, Fairfield, Shelton, and Trumbull consistently credit the office staff, named technicians (Miriam, Michael, Brian, Dave, Christian, Melanie, Joselyne), and the owner for making a stressful renovation feel straightforward.
The website lists over a decade in business and an A+ Better Business Bureau rating. Service offerings span roof repairs, replacements, siding and window installation, gutters, and emergency work. Pricing appears fair relative to the quality delivered-reviewers specifically note competitive costs-and the company handles everything from permits to final walkthrough. No negative patterns appear in recent reviews.
A Plus Exterior LLC
A Plus Exterior delivers consistent results across roof and gutter work in Milford. Crews show up on time, handle debris professionally (tarps, magnets, prompt dumpster removal), and stay in touch during and after jobs. Leadership (Alex, Ray) quotes promptly and handles surprises like hidden rot without sticker shock.
Reviewers praise the team's speed, workmanship, and tidiness across roof replacement, repairs, gutters, siding, and windows. One installer fixed a gutter color mix-up within 24 hours. A crew of eight completed a full roof replacement in one day while managing old shingles with specialized lift equipment. Follow-up calls confirm satisfaction months later.
Which should you pick?
Pick Cruz Roofing and Siding if
- Your gutter or siding job is tied to an insurance claim and you want one company managing the paperwork start to finish.
- You're in Westport, Fairfield, Shelton, or Trumbull and want continuity with named crew and office staff.
- The job involves a complicated roofline or a multi-phase exterior remodel alongside the gutters and siding.
Pick A Plus Exterior LLC if
- You want an Owens Corning Platinum Certified installer or a HAAG-certified inspection before work starts.
- You're in the Milford area and need a fast fix on something small, like a gutter color mismatch or an emergency leak.
- The job involves heavy tear-off debris and you want magnetic sweeps and lift equipment on site.
Verdict
Fit depends on what's driving the job. If a storm claim is involved and you want one contractor to own the insurance process end to end, Cruz Roofing and Siding's track record on complex jobs and claims handling fits better. If you want manufacturer-backed certification and a crew that moves fast on smaller gutter and siding fixes, A Plus Exterior is the stronger match. Both carry a 4.9 rating with a positive sentiment profile, so the deciding factor is the type of job, not the score.
Need help choosing a contractor?
Describe the job once and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Connecticut.
Enquiries you submit through this site's forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published scoring method and are not influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which one has more reviews?
- Cruz Roofing and Siding has 206 Google reviews versus A Plus Exterior's 154, both averaging 4.9 stars.
- Which is better for a storm-damage insurance claim?
- Cruz Roofing and Siding, based on reviewer praise for managing the insurance claims process from inspection through approval.
- Which one carries manufacturer certifications?
- A Plus Exterior LLC is listed as a Platinum Certified Owens Corning contractor and HAAG certified for roof inspections.
- Are both good choices specifically for gutters and siding?
- Yes, both list gutters and siding among their services alongside roofing, with positive sentiment in reviews covering both trades.