Best roofing contractors in Middletown
These are the 11 roofing contractors serving Middletown that we could find and score, ranked by an earned composite drawn from our methodology: rating, review volume, recency, sentiment, and profile completeness. Most of these crews handle the same core work (replacement, repair, gutters, storm damage), so the order below comes down to who backs it up with the strongest track record.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to roofing contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Monarch Roofing | 94 | 5 (172) | — | Full replacements & fast turnarounds |
| 2 | LA ROOFING LLC | 88 | 4.9 (383) | — | Largest track record & emergency response |
| 3 | Crestline Home | 88 | 5 (51) | — | Storm damage restoration with lifetime warranty |
| 4 | New horizons construction LLC | 78 | 5 (6) | — | Multi-trade jobs beyond just the roof |
| 5 | Gold Seal Roofing , LLC | 57 | 5 (1) | — | Decades of experience, thin recent record |
| 6 | Imperial Roofing & Home Improvement | 56 | 5 (2) | — | Major damage repair |
| 7 | Leading Edge Exteriors LLC | 50 | 5 (1) | — | Newer profile, worth a second quote |
| 8 | Strongtech Roofing | 49 | 3 (2) | — | Additional quote to compare |
| 9 | Paramount Roofing | 30 | — | — | Unrated, early-stage option |
| 10 | LaBranch Roofing | 26 | — | — | Unrated, early-stage option |
| 11 | JStokes Roofing | 22 | — | — | Unrated, early-stage option |
1. Monarch Roofing
5 (172 reviews)score 94/100
The top composite score in Middletown belongs to Monarch, built on 172 five-star reviews and the same familiar names (Mike, Melanie, Dru, Rob) showing up job after job. Installations wrap in a single day with a supervisor on-site and daily cleanup, and reviewers report no pushback when issues turn up after inspection.
- Owner-operated, with Mike and Melanie hands-on across jobs
- Supervisor present on-site during installs
- One-day roof replacements with thorough daily cleanup and plant protection
- Fast scheduling and clear communication throughout
Watch out: Full replacements aren't the cheapest quote in town, though reviewers say the price holds up against competitors once quality is factored in.
Services: 24 7 emergency roofing, roof replacement installation, roof repair, roof inspection insurance
2. LA ROOFING LLC
4.9 (383 reviews)score 88/100
With 383 reviews at 4.9 stars, LA Roofing has the deepest track record among Middletown roofers, and a foreman or project manager stays on-site for most jobs. Crews handle surprises like hidden rot honestly and fix them on the spot, and the company has answered emergency calls as early as 7am for ice dam removal.
- On-time crews (Brandon, Luis, Ryan, Michael) with steady updates
- Thorough cleanup, including nails swept up with a magnet
- Project manager on-site for most jobs
- Warranty callbacks for leaks handled promptly
Watch out: A handful of reviews mention details slipping through, like a promised roof vent not installed or before-and-after photos left incomplete.
Services: 24 7 emergency roofing, roof repair, roof inspection insurance, roof replacement installation
3. Crestline Home
5 (51 reviews)score 88/100
Crestline's 51 reviews are all five-star, describing an organized process from initial damage assessment through final cleanup. Every installation comes with a lifetime warranty, and the crew walks homeowners through repair options before work starts.
- Lifetime warranty on roof installations
- Zero complaints across 51 recent reviews
- Efficient crews that don't cut corners
- Clear upfront explanation of damage and repair options
Watch out: Its review count is smaller than the two contractors above it, though the feedback on record is uniformly positive.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof inspection insurance
4. New horizons construction LLC
5 (6 reviews)score 78/100
A perfect 5.0 across its reviews backs New Horizons, where Javier's crew completes roof replacements in a single day and also takes on siding, flooring, tile, and bathroom work. Landlords and homeowners cite fair pricing and reliable communication.
- One-day roof replacements
- Also handles siding, flooring, tile, and bathroom work
Watch out: Its rating is built on just 6 reviews so far, a smaller sample than the contractors above it.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation
5. Gold Seal Roofing , LLC
5 (1 reviews)score 57/100
Over 30 years in business and state and federal certifications set Gold Seal apart, though its one review on file (five years old) is the only recent evidence of an extremely professional experience. There isn't enough recent review volume yet to judge consistency.
- Over 30 years in business
- State and federal certifications
Watch out: Only one review is on record, and it dates back five years, so recent performance is hard to confirm.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair
6. Imperial Roofing & Home Improvement
5 (2 reviews)score 56/100
Two reviews from around four years ago describe Imperial's crews as punctual, thorough with cleanup, and skilled at handling major damage repair. There isn't much recent data to confirm how the business performs today.
- Punctual arrival and completion, per reviewers
- Thorough post-job cleanup
Watch out: Both reviews are several years old and there are only two of them, so treat this as a starting point for research, not a full picture.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation
7. Leading Edge Exteriors LLC
5 (1 reviews)score 50/100
A single 5-star review is what's on file for Leading Edge Exteriors, not enough recent activity to draw a reliable read on typical service. It's worth a call for a quote alongside the more established options on this list.
- Its one review on record is a 5-star rating
- Listed among Middletown's active roofing contractors
Watch out: Review volume is too low right now to judge consistency, so lean on the businesses above it for a stronger track record.
Services: gutter services, roof repair
8. Strongtech Roofing
3 (2 reviews)score 49/100
Just two reviews are on file for Strongtech, averaging 3 stars, which isn't enough activity to say much about typical service quality. It appears in Middletown's roofing directory but with far less evidence behind it than the contractors ranked above.
- Has an active profile among Middletown roofing contractors
Watch out: Its 3-star average comes from only two reviews, and there isn't enough recent feedback to know what to expect.
Services: roof repair
9. Paramount Roofing
score 30/100
No reviews are on record yet for Paramount Roofing, so there's no rating history to evaluate here. It's included for completeness, though homeowners should verify licensing and get references directly before hiring.
- Appears in Middletown's roofing contractor directory
Watch out: Zero reviews on file means there's no track record here to lean on.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair
10. LaBranch Roofing
score 26/100
No reviews are on record for LaBranch Roofing, leaving no rating history to draw on for this ranking. It's included for completeness, though it's worth confirming licensing and recent references before hiring.
- Appears in Middletown's roofing contractor directory
Watch out: Zero reviews on file means there's no track record here to lean on.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation
11. JStokes Roofing
score 22/100
No reviews are on record yet for JStokes Roofing, and its public profile is less complete than the others here. Treat it as a lead to verify independently rather than a proven choice.
- Appears in Middletown's roofing contractor directory
Watch out: Zero reviews on file means there's no track record here to lean on.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation