Best gutters & siding contractors in New Haven
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to gutters & siding, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pro Exteriors LLC | 93 | 4.9 (452) | — | Full exterior overhaul, gutters and siding together |
| 2 | Girardi's Restoration | 80 | 4.8 (23) | — | Owner-supervised exterior repair with hidden-damage checks |
| 3 | Construction Mutants LLC | 78 | 5 (12) | — | Fast, fairly priced exterior jobs with named crew |
| 4 | Giant Roofing | 75 | 5 (11) | — | Diagnosing exterior problems other companies missed |
| 5 | Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc. | 68 | 5 (1) | — | Long-established, certified exterior work |
1. Pro Exteriors LLC
4.9 (452 reviews)score 93/100
Pro Exteriors runs the deepest exterior operation on this list, installing gutters with guards and siding alongside roofing and trim work, all under one crew led by owner Charles. With 452 reviews at a 4.9 average, the volume behind that score is far larger than any other name here, which makes the pattern of praise easier to trust.
- Gutters with guards and full siding installs, not just repairs
- Detailed estimates with product specs and drone photos
- Proactive updates with progress photos during the job
- Thorough daily cleanup and final site restoration
Services: roof inspection insurance, 24 7 emergency roofing, gutter services, roof repair
2. Girardi's Restoration
4.8 (23 reviews)score 80/100
John runs Girardi's Restoration hands-on, and reviewers point to careful inspection work that catches hidden wood damage before siding or trim goes back on. The 4.8 rating comes from a smaller pool of 23 reviews, so it's a solid track record rather than a huge one.
- Owner-operator present on jobs
- Checks for hidden wood damage before closing up work
- Full daily cleanup on multi-day jobs
- Long-standing repeat customer relationships
Watch out: One reviewer described a failed repair and trouble getting a callback afterward, worth asking about warranty terms upfront.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services, 24 7 emergency roofing
3. Construction Mutants LLC
5 (12 reviews)score 78/100
Construction Mutants has a perfect 5.0 average across three years of reviews, with Yener and Romero named repeatedly for clear explanations and same-day turnarounds. The review count of 12 is modest, so treat the score as promising but still building a track record.
- Fair pricing called out consistently
- Named technicians with a strong repeat track record
- Often finishes jobs in a single day
- Returns to sweep and clean up debris
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services
4. Giant Roofing
5 (11 reviews)score 75/100
Giant Roofing's 11 reviews are all five stars, with several customers noting the crew found leaks and issues that previous contractors had overlooked. A labor warranty backs the work, which fits with reviewers who chose the company on quality over lowest price.
- Diagnoses complex leaks and exterior issues others miss
- Available same-day for urgent repairs
- No-pressure, transparent explanations of the work needed
- Labor warranty included
Watch out: Review volume is still low (11), so the track record is strong but early.
Services: metal roofing, gutter services, roof repair, 24 7 emergency roofing
5. Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc.
5 (1 reviews)score 68/100
Pawcatuck Roofing has operated since 1946 and carries GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certification, which covers both roofing and siding product lines. Only one review is on record so far, describing fast, professional, on-budget work, so this is a low-confidence pick worth a direct conversation before booking.
- Operating since 1946
- GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certified
Watch out: Based on a single review, so there isn't much data yet to confirm consistency.
Services: gutter services, roof repair, roof replacement installation, metal roofing
How these rankings are worked out
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 16% |
| Review recency | 10% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-25 · Full methodology ›