Best gutters & siding contractors in New Haven
These are the six New Haven contractors who treat gutters and siding as a core part of their business, not an add-on, ranked using our methodology of ratings, review volume, recency, and sentiment.
Looking for a roofer instead? See our separate list of the best roofing contractors overall, which ranks that trade on its own terms.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to gutters & siding, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pro Exteriors LLC | 93 | 4.9 (446) | — | All-round gutter & siding jobs |
| 2 | DAFA Construction LLC | 83 | 4.9 (46) | — | Multi-trade projects with siding |
| 3 | Girardi's Restoration | 80 | 4.8 (23) | — | Detail-focused siding repairs |
| 4 | Construction Mutants LLC | 78 | 5 (12) | — | Fast, budget-friendly gutter work |
| 5 | Giant Roofing | 76 | 5 (11) | — | Tricky diagnostic repairs |
| 6 | Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc. | 68 | 5 (1) | — | Long-established, certified crews |
1. Pro Exteriors LLC
4.9 (446 reviews)score 93/100
Pro Exteriors backs up a near-perfect rating across 446 reviews, the largest and freshest review base on this list, with siding and gutter work reviewers describe as still holding up years later. Charles and his crews are called out repeatedly for detailed estimates with drone photos, staying on schedule, and pricing that beat other quotes.
- Owner-led consultations with photo-backed estimates
- Gutters installed with guards as standard
- Free follow-up adjustments and warranty support
- Clean jobsite left daily
Services: roof inspection insurance, 24 7 emergency roofing, roof repair, metal roofing
2. DAFA Construction LLC
4.9 (46 reviews)score 83/100
DAFA Construction pairs siding and roofing work with kitchen and bath trades, run by an owner who's directly involved in permitting and problem-solving. Reviewers highlight daily jobsite cleanup and a willingness to catch structural issues before they get expensive, backed by a strong 4.9 rating.
- Handles roofing and siding end-to-end alongside other trades
- Owner Fabian pulls permits and advises on materials
- Adapts to scope changes without extra hassle
- Cleans up daily with regular text updates
Watch out: A couple of reviewers mention project timelines running longer than initially quoted.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, gutter services
3. Girardi's Restoration
4.8 (23 reviews)score 80/100
Girardi's Restoration earns praise for owner-operator John's hands-on attention to detail, including catching hidden wood damage before it becomes a bigger job. With 23 reviews at a 4.8 average, it's a smaller but well-regarded outfit for siding and exterior repair work.
- Owner-operator involved on every job
- Spots hidden wood damage before starting
- Fast single-day turnarounds with full cleanup
- Repeat customers and long-term relationships
Watch out: One reviewer reported a failed repair and difficulty getting a callback afterward.
Services: gutter services
4. Construction Mutants LLC
5 (12 reviews)score 78/100
Every one of Construction Mutants' 12 reviews is five stars, with Yener and Romero named directly for clear communication and thorough cleanup. It's a smaller review base, but three years of consistent praise for fair pricing makes it a solid pick for straightforward gutter and siding jobs.
- Fair, consistently praised pricing
- Named technicians with strong track records
- Often finishes jobs in a single day
- Thorough debris cleanup after work
Watch out: Review volume is lower, so the track record is thinner than the top picks.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services
5. Giant Roofing
5 (11 reviews)score 76/100
Giant Roofing's 11 reviews are all five stars, with several customers specifically noting the crew found leaks other companies had missed. Fair pricing and a labor warranty back up the work, though the review count is still small.
- Diagnoses leaks other contractors missed
- Same-day emergency work available
- No-pressure, transparent explanations
- Labor warranty included
Watch out: Not yet verified on our platform, and the review count is still modest.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair, metal roofing, roof replacement installation
6. Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc.
5 (1 reviews)score 68/100
Pawcatuck Roofing has been operating since 1946 and holds GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certifications, though its online review presence is minimal with just one review so far. That single review describes fast, professional, budget-conscious repair work with proper cleanup.
- Operating since 1946
- GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certified
Watch out: Only one review on record, so there's not much data to judge consistency.
Services: roof repair, flat roofing commercial, metal roofing, roof replacement installation