Best roofing contractors in New Haven
This ranking covers 15 roofing contractors serving New Haven, scored on review volume, rating, recency, and sentiment using our methodology. All handle roof replacement or repair; most also cover gutters, siding, and flashing in the same visit.
Gutter and siding specialists are ranked separately on our best gutters & siding page. This list focuses on roofing scope, though several contractors here overlap into those trades too.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to roofing contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pro Exteriors LLC | 93 | 4.9 (446) | — | Full-scope roofing and exteriors |
| 2 | DAFA Construction LLC | 83 | 4.9 (46) | — | Multi-trade projects (roof plus renovation) |
| 3 | Upscale Construction | 80 | 4.8 (26) | — | Large-scale and commercial roofing |
| 4 | Girardi's Restoration | 80 | 4.8 (23) | — | Single-day roof replacement |
| 5 | Construction Mutants LLC | 78 | 5 (12) | — | Fast, fairly priced re-roofs |
| 6 | Giant Roofing | 76 | 5 (11) | — | Diagnosing leaks others missed |
| 7 | Restoration Roofing LLC | 74 | 4.8 (17) | — | Quick turnaround on roof and gutters |
| 8 | AED Roofers Water Proofers | 74 | 5 (7) | — | Solving chronic leak problems |
| 9 | R&C Roofing and Chimney Sweep Cleaning Services Co | 71 | 4.9 (8) | — | Combined roof and chimney work |
| 10 | H&R Roofing & Remodeling and Air Duct Cleaning Services | 70 | 5 (6) | — | Multi-system home projects |
| 11 | Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc. | 68 | 5 (1) | — | Long-established, certified roofing |
| 12 | Budget Roofing Services | 60 | 5 (1) | — | Budget-conscious repairs |
| 13 | CT Roofing Services | 56 | 5 (2) | — | Repeat-customer trust |
| 14 | G L Capasso Inc | 52 | 4.1 (9) | — | roof repair |
| 15 | Dfd Roofing Llc | 51 | 5 (2) | — | roof repair |
1. Pro Exteriors LLC
4.9 (446 reviews)score 93/100
Pro Exteriors LLC carries the highest composite score in New Haven on the strength of 446 reviews at a 4.9 average, which is a rare combination of volume and consistency. Charles and his crews cover roof replacement, repair, emergency work, gutters, siding, flashing, skylights, and metal roofing, and reviewers say pricing beat competing quotes even before factoring in the free follow-up adjustments.
- Owner Charles leads consultations personally with drone photos and detailed estimates
- Jobsite cleaned daily, work often finishes ahead of schedule
- Pricing came in below other bids reviewers collected
- Free follow-up adjustments and warranty support after the job
Services: roof inspection insurance, 24 7 emergency roofing, roof repair, metal roofing
2. DAFA Construction LLC
4.9 (46 reviews)score 83/100
DAFA Construction pairs roofing and siding with kitchen and bathroom work, run by Fabian since a business claimed operating since 1989 with HIC registration on file. Reviewers highlight permit handling, materials guidance, and crews that catch structural problems before they get expensive.
- Handles roofing, siding, and multi-trade renovation in one contract
- Owner Fabian involved directly in permitting and problem-solving
- Daily jobsite cleanup with text updates to customers
- Adapts to scope changes without friction
Watch out: One customer said the initial timeline estimate ran optimistic, though the finished work justified the wait.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, gutter services
3. Upscale Construction
4.8 (26 reviews)score 80/100
Upscale Construction shows up in reviews for industrial, multifamily, and adaptive reuse projects delivered on time and on budget, with David named repeatedly for reliability. It's a good match if the job is bigger than a single-family roof.
- Design-build and adaptive reuse experience
- Manages renovation programs spanning hundreds to thousands of units
- Handles complex compliance needs (USDA, Kosher)
- Fast, professional communication throughout
Watch out: Review volume is lighter than the top two, so the track record is solid but smaller in sample size.
Services: metal roofing
4. Girardi's Restoration
4.8 (23 reviews)score 80/100
Girardi's Restoration is an owner-operator business where John runs jobs personally, with reviewers pointing to rapid single-day roof replacements and hidden wood damage caught before it becomes a bigger repair. Years of consistent five-star feedback back up the craftsmanship claims.
- Owner-operator involvement on every job
- Same-day roof replacement with full site cleanup
- Detects hidden wood damage before work begins
- Long-standing repeat customer relationships
Watch out: One reviewer reported a failed repair with no response to follow-up calls, worth asking about directly.
Services: gutter services
5. Construction Mutants LLC
5 (12 reviews)score 78/100
Construction Mutants LLC has a perfect rating across three years of reviews, with Yener and Romero named repeatedly for removing multiple roof layers and finishing in a single day. Confidence is medium given the smaller review count, but the sentiment is uniformly positive.
- Fair, reasonable pricing noted across reviews
- Named technicians with a strong repeat track record
- Often completes jobs in one day
- Returns to sweep and clean up debris after the fact
Watch out: Review volume is modest (12), so the pattern is encouraging but not yet as proven as the top performers.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services
6. Giant Roofing
5 (11 reviews)score 76/100
Giant Roofing earns a perfect rating across all 11 reviews, with several customers specifically noting the crew found leaks that other companies had missed. Same-day emergency work and a labor warranty back up the confidence in their repairs.
- Diagnoses complex leaks other contractors overlooked
- Works same-day on emergency calls
- Explains conditions clearly without sales pressure
- Labor warranty included on work
Watch out: No verification badge on file yet, and the review base is still under a dozen.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair, metal roofing, roof replacement installation
7. Restoration Roofing LLC
4.8 (17 reviews)score 74/100
Restoration Roofing LLC is run hands-on by Edgar and Lucero, who inspect and quote jobs personally and typically finish roof, gutter, fascia, and flashing work in one or two days. Years of five-star reviews praise the speed and attention to detail.
- Owner and wife inspect and quote every job personally
- Same-day or next-day turnaround typical
- Transparent pricing and insurance shown upfront
- Covers roof, gutters, fascia, and flashing together
Watch out: One recent job had crew delays and incomplete cleanup, a departure from the usual pattern.
Services: roof inspection insurance
8. AED Roofers Water Proofers
5 (7 reviews)score 74/100
AED Roofers Water Proofers has a perfect five-star record across seven reviews, including one customer with a long-running leak history who says Ezekiel's team finally fixed it for good. Confidence is low given the small sample, but every review points the same direction.
- Owner Ezekiel brings deep, hands-on expertise
- Resolved a chronic leak issue other attempts failed to fix
Watch out: Only seven reviews on record, so treat the pattern as promising rather than fully proven.
Services: flat roofing commercial
9. R&C Roofing and Chimney Sweep Cleaning Services Co
4.9 (8 reviews)score 71/100
R&C Roofing and Chimney Sweep Cleaning Services pairs roof repair with chimney and duct work in a single visit, with named staff (Brian, John, Austin, Mike, Ryan) earning praise for clear written estimates and honest pricing. All eight reviews land at four or five stars.
- Thorough inspections with clear, written estimates
- Honest pricing with no hidden costs reported
Watch out: Review count is small (8) and recency score is lower than others on this list.
Services: metal roofing
10. H&R Roofing & Remodeling and Air Duct Cleaning Services
5 (6 reviews)score 70/100
H&R Roofing & Remodeling and Air Duct Cleaning Services draws six perfect reviews, with Justin and Alan cited for on-site supervision and fast, accurate problem diagnosis. Reviewers say the finished work visibly increased home resale value.
- Technicians supervise on-site rather than leaving crews unattended
- Daily cleanup before leaving the property
Watch out: Only six reviews so far, and no verification badge is on file yet.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation
11. Pawcatuck Roofing Company Inc.
5 (1 reviews)score 68/100
Pawcatuck Roofing Company has operated since 1946 and holds GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certification, covering both residential and commercial roofing plus coatings and inspections. The one review on file describes fast, professional repair work completed within budget.
- Manufacturer-certified (GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed)
- Decades of operating history since 1946
Watch out: Only one review is on record, so the certification and history carry more weight here than review volume.
Services: roof repair, flat roofing commercial, metal roofing, roof replacement installation
12. Budget Roofing Services
5 (1 reviews)score 60/100
Budget Roofing Services has a single five-star review on file, which isn't enough yet to draw a firm read on typical customer experience. It's included here for completeness at the lower end of the confidence range.
- Perfect rating on the one review available
Watch out: Too few reviews to gauge consistency; ask for references before committing to a larger job.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance
13. CT Roofing Services
5 (2 reviews)score 56/100
CT Roofing Services has a small but notable pattern: both reviewers used the company twice, with one returning four years later because the first job held up so well. Jonathan is named for quoting fairly and finishing on schedule.
- Repeat customers who came back years later
- Transparent quotes and timelines
Watch out: Only two reviews on record, and the recency score is at the low end.
Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair
14. G L Capasso Inc
4.1 (9 reviews)score 52/100
G L Capasso Inc has a mixed history of prior positive work, but recent one-star reviews describe serious interpersonal complaints, including discriminatory conduct. This one carries the lowest sentiment score on the list and should be approached with caution.
Watch out: Recent reviews describe disrespectful and discriminatory conduct toward customers; this is a serious flag, not a minor gripe.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation
15. Dfd Roofing Llc
5 (2 reviews)score 51/100
Dfd Roofing Llc has only two reviews on file and not enough recent activity to form a reliable read on typical customer experience. It rounds out this list at the lower-confidence end.
Watch out: Too little review data yet to assess consistency; get a detailed written quote before proceeding.
Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance