Best roofing contractors in New Haven

★★★★★4.9 (452 reviews)score 93/100

Pro Exteriors combines the highest composite score on this list with the deepest review base by far, 452 reviews at 4.9 stars. Charles and his crew are repeatedly credited with finishing big jobs ahead of schedule while keeping sites spotless and pricing transparent.

• Fast turnaround even on large, multi-day jobs
• Detailed estimates with product specs and drone photos
• Proactive updates and progress photos during the job
• Thorough daily cleanup and stands behind work a year later

Services: roof inspection insurance, 24 7 emergency roofing, gutter services, roof repair

★★★★★5 (9 reviews)score 80/100

Every one of AED's nine reviews is five stars, with a standout case of resolving moisture issues that a prior contractor's failed rubber roof installation left behind. The review count is modest, but the pattern of on-time arrival and careful cleanup is consistent.

• Punctual, responsive crew with meticulous cleanup
• Certified and insured, over a decade in business

Watch out: Only 9 reviews on record, so the sample is smaller than the top names on this list.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, flat roofing commercial

★★★★★4.8 (23 reviews)score 80/100

John runs jobs personally and reviewers describe careful attention to detail, including catching hidden wood damage before work starts. One reviewer did report a repair that failed with no follow-up response, which is worth weighing against years of otherwise strong feedback.

• Owner-operator involved directly in every job
• Single-day roof replacements with full site cleanup
• Detects hidden wood rot before it becomes a bigger problem
• Long-standing repeat customers

Watch out: One reviewer reported a failed repair and difficulty reaching the crew for a follow-up fix.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services, 24 7 emergency roofing

★★★★★4.8 (26 reviews)score 79/100

Upscale leans toward larger-scale and adaptive-reuse construction work, with David and the team named repeatedly for keeping industrial and multifamily projects on time and on budget. It's a strong fit if the job involves compliance requirements like USDA or Kosher certification.

• Handles design-build and adaptive reuse projects
• Manages renovation programs across hundreds of units
• Navigates complex compliance requirements
• Named staff cited by reviewers for reliability

Services: roof repair, metal roofing

★★★★★5 (12 reviews)score 78/100

Construction Mutants has a perfect 5-star average across three years of reviews, with Yener and Romero named repeatedly for removing multiple roof layers and explaining the work clearly as they go. Jobs tend to move fast, often wrapping in a single day.

• Fair and reasonable pricing consistently noted
• Named technicians with a strong track record
• Often completes jobs in a single day
• Returns to sweep up debris after the job

Watch out: Review volume is still relatively light at 12, though the sentiment is uniformly positive.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services

★★★★★5 (11 reviews)score 75/100

Giant Roofing's 11 reviews are all five stars, with several customers noting the crew found leaks that other contractors had missed. One reviewer specifically chose them over cheaper bids because quality mattered more, and the labor warranty backs that up.

• Diagnoses complex leaks other companies missed
• Works same-day on emergency calls
• Explains conditions clearly with no sales pressure
• Backs work with a labor warranty

Services: metal roofing, gutter services, roof repair, 24 7 emergency roofing

★★★★★4.8 (17 reviews)score 74/100

Edgar and Lucero handle most calls and inspections personally at Restoration Roofing, and jobs typically wrap in one or two days covering roof, gutters, fascia, and flashing together. One recent job had crew delays and incomplete cleanup, a rare miss against a longer run of five-star feedback.

• Same-day or next-day turnaround is typical
• Owner and spouse inspect and quote jobs personally
• Transparent pricing and insurance shown upfront
• Covers roof, gutters, fascia and flashing in one visit

Watch out: A recent review flagged crew punctuality and cleanup that fell short of their usual standard.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, metal roofing

★★★★★4.6 (8 reviews)score 74/100

R&C pairs roof leak repair with chimney sweeping and inspection in single visits, and reviewers across multiple jobs describe prompt responses and clear explanations of what's wrong. Several named staff members get specific praise for professionalism.

• Quick leak detection and repair
• Combines roofing and chimney work in one visit

Watch out: Review count is on the lower side at 8, so treat the pattern as promising rather than fully proven.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance

★★★★★4.7 (6 reviews)score 73/100

H&R's reviewers highlight jobs that stumped other contractors, from chimney restoration to elusive roof leaks, with Mike, Justin, and Alan named for careful, explained work. One reviewer specifically noted the finished work added value to the home.

• Named technicians get specific praise for expertise
• Takes on complex problems other contractors couldn't solve

Watch out: Only 6 reviews so far, making this a smaller sample than most names on this list.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 68/100

Pawcatuck has operated since 1946 and carries GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certifications, covering both residential and commercial work plus coatings and inspections. The single review on file is strongly positive, but there isn't much recent feedback to lean on.

• Operating since 1946
• GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed certified

Watch out: Only one review on record, so the composite score reflects low confidence despite the long history.

Services: gutter services, roof repair, roof replacement installation, metal roofing

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 60/100

There isn't enough recent review activity yet to say much about typical customer experience here beyond the single five-star rating on file. Worth a call for a quote if the name fits the budget, but go in with fewer data points than the names above.

• Five-star rating on the one review available

Watch out: Too few reviews to establish a reliable pattern of service quality.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, gutter services

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)score 56/100

Both of CT Roofing's reviewers used the company twice, which says something on its own: one customer returned four years after a job at a family member's house went well. Jonathan is named for fair quotes and finishing on schedule.

• Repeat customers who came back years later
• Transparent quotes and timelines

Watch out: Only 2 reviews on file, so this is a low-confidence score despite the positive tone.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, metal roofing

★★★★☆4.1 (9 reviews)score 53/100

G L Capasso's older reviews don't say much about roofing craftsmanship one way or the other, but recent one-star reviews describe seriously disrespectful and discriminatory conduct toward customers. That pulls the composite score down well below the rest of this list.

Watch out: Recent reviews describe rude, discriminatory, and unprofessional conduct; get a clear sense of who you'd be dealing with before booking.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, metal roofing

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)score 51/100

DFD Roofing has only two reviews on file and not enough recent activity to establish a reliable read on typical service quality. It may be worth a quote, but go in expecting to do your own vetting.

Watch out: Sentiment is mixed and review volume is too low to draw firm conclusions.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance

★★★★☆4 (4 reviews)score 51/100

Manoly is licensed and insured and covers multiple roof types across Connecticut counties, but the two available reviews split sharply: one customer was very happy, another reported shingles installed over rotted plywood without proper underlayment. With only four reviews total, that split is hard to explain away.

• Licensed and insured
• Works across all Connecticut counties

Watch out: One reviewer reported shingles installed over rotted plywood without underlayment; ask detailed questions about installation steps before hiring.

Services: metal roofing, roof repair, roof replacement installation, flat roofing commercial