Best roofing contractors in New London

★★★★★5 (27 reviews)score 85/100

SERVPRO of New London posts a perfect 5.0 average across 27 reviews and the highest composite score on this list, built on fast emergency response and named technicians who see projects through from first call to final walkthrough. The team handles insurance paperwork directly and keeps customers updated through multi-week jobs. Most reviews describe water damage and mold work rather than roof jobs specifically, so it's worth confirming roofing-crew experience when you call.

• Same-day emergency response
• Handles insurance claims directly
• IICRC certified technicians
• Named staff manage the job start to finish

Watch out: Most reviews on file describe water and mold restoration rather than roofing specifically, so confirm roofing-crew experience before booking.

Services: roof repair, 24 7 emergency roofing, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance

★★★★★4.7 (71 reviews)score 82/100

AM-PM Roofing runs a close second with a 4.7 average across 71 reviews, the largest review base on this list, and owner Paul personally inspecting jobs before any work starts. Customers repeatedly mention same-day replacements, careful cleanup, and Paul flagging hidden damage rather than padding the invoice. A couple of recent reviews describe a missed appointment and unresolved siding staining, worth asking about directly.

• Owner Paul personally inspects and often works every job
• Same-day replacements are common
• Discloses hidden damage before charging for it
• Thorough jobsite cleanup

Watch out: A couple of recent reviews cite a no-show appointment and slow follow-up on siding staining.

Services: roof repair, gutter services, 24 7 emergency roofing, flat roofing commercial

★★★★★5 (12 reviews)score 81/100

Brewster Home Improvement holds a perfect 5.0 across all 12 reviews on file, with reviewers repeatedly calling out Travis's craftsmanship and Erica's project coordination. Work covers roofing alongside gutters, doors, windows, and interiors, and several customers have hired the crew repeatedly over multiple years. The review count is smaller than the leaders above, so the sample is still growing.

• Consistent praise for craftsmanship and attention to detail
• Punctual, clean jobsites
• Clear communication and updates from Erica
• Multiple repeat customers over the years

Services: roof replacement installation, roof repair, gutter services

★★★★★4.6 (30 reviews)score 77/100

SJM Roofing averages 4.6 stars across 30 reviews, with customers pointing to Shaun's clear explanations, punctual crews, and thorough site cleanup. The company backs its work with over 20 years of experience and documents jobs with video and written records. Around 10% of its reviews are negative and aren't detailed in the available sentiment summary, so it's worth reading the full review history before deciding.

• Over 20 years in business
• Video and written documentation of completed work
• Punctual, respectful crews
• Clear upfront explanations from Shaun

Watch out: About 10% of reviews are negative and not reflected in the praise summary here, so check the full review history.

Services: roof repair, gutter services, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance

★★★★★4.9 (17 reviews)score 72/100

The Superior Group draws near-universal five-star praise across 17 reviews for commercial and residential roofs, including flat, silicone, and metal systems. Reviewers describe fast timelines, clean sites, and transparent pricing from first call through project close. The one complaint on file, a missed quote follow-up, dates back roughly four years.

• Versico Certified and Everest Systems Platinum Contractor
• 17 years operating in the area
• Transparent, fair quoting process
• Handles flat, silicone, and metal commercial roofs

Watch out: One older review, about four years back, mentions a quote that was never followed up on.

Services: roof repair, flat roofing commercial, roof replacement installation, metal roofing

★★★★★5 (13 reviews)score 67/100

T.J. Nelson Home Improvements holds a perfect 5.0 across 13 reviews, with customers citing fair pricing, honest dealing, and over 25 years of consistent client relationships. There's no critical feedback on file to weigh against the praise. The reviews behind that score haven't been refreshed recently, so it's worth confirming current availability and pricing directly.

• 25+ years of client relationships
• Fair, transparent contract pricing
• Reliable, punctual scheduling
• Described as honest and trustworthy

Watch out: Its reviews haven't been refreshed recently, so confirm current pricing and availability directly.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation

★★★★★5 (3 reviews)score 61/100

DC Property Management and Maintenance carries a perfect 5.0 rating, with owner Daryl responding personally to issues and completing projects on time. It handles both residential and commercial work at competitive pricing. The sample is thin, just 3 reviews, all from around three years ago, so treat the rating as a promising but limited data point.

• Owner Daryl responds directly to customers
• On-time project completion

Watch out: Only 3 reviews are on file, all dating back about three years, so recent performance is harder to confirm.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation

★★★★★5 (4 reviews)score 58/100

Chopa Contracting Services earns praise for expert leak detection and commercial flat roofing at competitive pricing, with both available reviews landing at 5 stars. That said, the reviews behind this score are about nine years old, so current crew and pricing should be verified before hiring. Treat this as a lead worth a phone call rather than a settled choice.

• Praised for diagnosing difficult leaks
• Commercial flat roofing expertise

Watch out: The reviews on file are around nine years old, so current service quality is unconfirmed.

Services: roof repair, flat roofing commercial, roof replacement installation, gutter services

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)score 55/100

Thermalfit's two reviews both land at 5 stars, praising quality materials and fair pricing, and the company holds Certainteed Master Shingler and Siding certifications with roots dating back to 1990. Financing is available for larger jobs. With only two reviews to go on, this is a promising but lightly-documented pick.

• Certainteed Master Shingler and Siding certified
• Operating since 1990

Watch out: Only two reviews are on file, so the rating is based on a very small sample.

Services: roof repair, gutter services, roof replacement installation

★★★★☆4.3 (11 reviews)score 55/100

G. A. Denison & Sons draws mostly five-star praise across 11 reviews for fast turnarounds and repairs that correct flashing and leak problems left by previous contractors, plus proactive post-storm follow-up calls. Two reviewers describe long waits and slow responses on smaller jobs, a real counterpoint to the praise. Long-standing customers from years back still speak well of the crew.

• Fixes leaks and flashing left by other contractors
• Proactive post-storm follow-up calls
• Aluminum-encapsulated fascia and rake board work
• Long customer retention

Watch out: Two reviewers report long waits and slow initial responses for smaller jobs.

Services: roof repair, gutter services, roof replacement installation, metal roofing

★★★☆☆3 (2 reviews)score 65/100

Roof, Siding, 1981 has just two reviews on file: one five-star mention of professional work and fair pricing, and one that pulls the average down to 3.0 overall. That split makes the current picture genuinely mixed rather than a clear recommendation either way. Worth a conversation to gauge current crew and pricing before committing.

• One reviewer cites professional, on-time work
• Fair pricing noted by at least one customer

Watch out: Only two reviews are on file and they disagree with each other, so the 3.0 average reflects a mixed, thin sample.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 50/100

Calles Roofing has one review on record, a 5-star rating, which isn't enough to establish a real pattern of service quality yet. There isn't complaint or sentiment data available to weigh against that single data point. Treat this as a name to check current references for rather than a settled pick.

• Sole review on file gives a 5-star rating
• No negative feedback reported so far

Watch out: Only one review exists, so there isn't enough evidence yet to judge consistency.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation

★☆☆☆☆1 (1 reviews)score 44/100

Di Roma Home Improvement has a single review on file, from about three years ago, and it's a negative one: the customer says the business never returned their contact. There isn't enough additional data to say whether that was a one-off or a pattern. It's included here for completeness, but the evidence available doesn't support a strong recommendation.

• Listed as an active roofing contractor in New London

Watch out: Its one review on file, from about three years ago, describes the business failing to return a customer's inquiry.

Services: roof repair

score 22/100

East Lyme Stucco & Waterproof has no Google reviews on file, so there's no customer feedback to evaluate its roofing work by. It appears in this list for completeness rather than on the strength of a track record. Get references directly before hiring.

• Listed as a local roofing and waterproofing contractor

Watch out: No reviews are on file, so there's no customer feedback to go on yet.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation

score 18/100

Quality Roofing Services of New London has no Google reviews on file, leaving nothing to judge its work quality by. It's included here for completeness given the evidence available. Ask for references and recent job photos directly before hiring.

• Listed as a roofing contractor serving New London

Watch out: No reviews are on file yet for this business.

Services: roof repair