R&A Remodeling & Roofing vs A Plus Exterior LLC: which roofer for your replacement?
R&A Remodeling & Roofing and A Plus Exterior LLC both turn up as strong picks for Roof Replacement & Installation, and the gap between them is thin enough that the right call depends on what you value most on install day. This breakdown follows our methodology to line up the differences that actually matter for a roof job, not just the headline scores.
The differences that matter
- Crew size and pace. A Plus Exterior fields a documented eight-person crew that stripped and replaced a full roof in one day using specialized lift equipment for old shingle removal, while R&A's pace is shown through fast one-day fixes on discovered secondary issues rather than a stated full-crew replacement timeline.
- Certifications for materials. A Plus Exterior carries Platinum Certified Owens Corning status plus HAAG certification for roof inspections, credentials R&A's summary does not mention.
- In-house permitting and inspections. R&A handles permitting and inspections itself, which can simplify the paperwork side of a replacement, whereas A Plus's strengths lean toward debris control and crew execution rather than permit handling.
- Job-progress visibility. R&A sends aerial photos and daily updates during the work, giving owners a running visual record of a multi-day tear-off and install, while A Plus's communication strength is centered on prompt quoting and after-job follow-up calls.
- Debris and site cleanup method. A Plus uses tarps, magnetic sweeps, and prompt dumpster removal to manage nail and shingle debris, a specific system not described in R&A's summary beyond leaving sites immaculate.
Side by side
- Google rating
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 5 (136 reviews)
- A Plus Exterior LLC: 4.9 (154 reviews)
- Services
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 24 7 emergency roofing, gutter services
- A Plus Exterior LLC: gutter services, roof inspection insurance, flat roofing commercial, roof repair
- Best for
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Owners who want daily photo updates and in-house permit handling on a replacement
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Owners who want a large crew finishing a full tear-off and reroof in a single day
- Specialties
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Slate leak repairs, full replacements, flashing and chimney work
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Roof replacement, repairs, gutters, siding, and windows with Owens Corning materials
- Verification
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Google-verified
- A Plus Exterior LLC: Google-verified
- Composite score
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 93
- A Plus Exterior LLC: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
R&A Remodeling & Roofing
Reviewers consistently experience fast, attentive service from a team led by Santos and Roger. Work spans slate leak repairs, full replacements, flashing and chimney work, with crews sending aerial photos during the job and leaving sites immaculate. One reviewer with a longstanding porch leak praised their proactive discovery of a second issue and one-day fix after heavy rain.
Materials arrive promptly (a week noted), and the outfit handles permitting and inspections in-house. Pricing lands as fair and competitive. Follow-up visits at no cost have resolved lingering concerns. All 136 reviews rate five stars, with no one-star complaints recorded.
A Plus Exterior LLC
A Plus Exterior delivers consistent results across roof and gutter work in Milford. Crews show up on time, handle debris professionally (tarps, magnets, prompt dumpster removal), and stay in touch during and after jobs. Leadership (Alex, Ray) quotes promptly and handles surprises like hidden rot without sticker shock.
Reviewers praise the team's speed, workmanship, and tidiness across roof replacement, repairs, gutters, siding, and windows. One installer fixed a gutter color mix-up within 24 hours. A crew of eight completed a full roof replacement in one day while managing old shingles with specialized lift equipment. Follow-up calls confirm satisfaction months later.
Which should you pick?
Pick R&A Remodeling & Roofing if
- You want in-house permitting and inspections handled without a separate contact
- You want daily aerial photos and progress updates during the tear-off and install
- You have a complex issue like flashing, chimney, or slate work alongside the main replacement
Pick A Plus Exterior LLC if
- You want an Owens Corning Platinum Certified installer for material-backed workmanship
- You want a large crew that can complete a full roof replacement in a single day
- You want a HAAG-certified inspection as part of assessing the roof before work starts
Verdict
The real decision point is not the half-point score gap, it's how each crew runs the job. R&A Remodeling & Roofing fits owners who want a hands-on, photo-documented process with permitting handled in-house, especially useful if the job includes flashing, chimney, or slate complications. A Plus Exterior LLC fits owners who want a larger crew, Owens Corning-certified materials, and a tightly managed one-day teardown-to-install with organized debris cleanup. Either contractor should deliver a solid replacement; the choice comes down to whether you prioritize documented daily oversight or certified speed and crew size.
Need help choosing a contractor?
Describe the job once and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Connecticut.
Enquiries you submit through this site's forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published scoring method and are not influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company is faster for a full roof replacement?
- A Plus Exterior has a documented case of an eight-person crew completing a full roof replacement in one day using lift equipment for shingle removal, which points to faster large-crew turnaround.
- Which contractor handles permits and inspections directly?
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing handles permitting and inspections in-house, according to its review summary.
- Does either contractor carry manufacturer certifications?
- A Plus Exterior is a Platinum Certified Owens Corning contractor and is HAAG certified for roof inspections; no manufacturer certification is mentioned for R&A.
- How do the two compare on communication during the job?
- R&A sends aerial photos and updates during work, while A Plus is noted for prompt quoting, same-day response to emergency leaks, and follow-up calls after the job.