R&A Remodeling & Roofing vs Fairfield Roofing: which handles a roofing emergency better?
When a roof is actively leaking, R&A Remodeling & Roofing and Fairfield Roofing are the two names that keep coming up as real alternatives for emergency callouts. Both run small, owner-involved teams with strong review records, but they differ in how that team is structured and what they emphasize once they're on the roof. Here's how they stack up, based on our methodology.
The differences that matter
- Who answers the call. R&A's crew is led by Santos and Roger with fast, attentive dispatch, while Fairfield Roofing is owner-operated with Sal personally answering the phone and showing up same-day or next-morning for storm damage.
- Repair philosophy. R&A leans into full diagnostics and proactive fixes, catching a second issue during a routine repair, whereas Fairfield Roofing explicitly favors repair-first work that avoids upselling into a full replacement.
- Track record at scale. R&A has a larger, spotless review base (136 five-star reviews, no complaints) against Fairfield Roofing's smaller but still strong base (63 reviews at 4.9), which matters when judging consistency under pressure.
- On-site communication during the job. R&A sends aerial photos and daily updates while work is underway, a level of visibility Fairfield Roofing's summary doesn't mention, though Fairfield's crew is noted for staying until the job is complete.
- Explicit emergency framing. Fairfield Roofing calls out weekend and holiday emergency response directly in its praise, while R&A's speed comes through in reviewer accounts (one-day fix after heavy rain) rather than an explicit around-the-clock claim.
Side by side
- Google rating
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 5 (136 reviews)
- Fairfield Roofing: 4.9 (63 reviews)
- Services
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 24 7 emergency roofing, gutter services
- Fairfield Roofing: roof inspection insurance, flat roofing commercial, roof repair, metal roofing
- Best for
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Larger jobs needing permitting, inspections, and full replacement handled in-house
- Fairfield Roofing: Quick, targeted repairs where you want a straight answer instead of a replacement pitch
- Temperament fit
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Structured, team-based response with heavy documentation of the work
- Fairfield Roofing: Personal, one-on-one contact with the owner from first call to finished repair
- Verification
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: Google-verified
- Fairfield Roofing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing: 93
- Fairfield Roofing: 87
What reviewers say
R&A Remodeling & Roofing
Reviewers consistently experience fast, attentive service from a team led by Santos and Roger. Work spans slate leak repairs, full replacements, flashing and chimney work, with crews sending aerial photos during the job and leaving sites immaculate. One reviewer with a longstanding porch leak praised their proactive discovery of a second issue and one-day fix after heavy rain.
Materials arrive promptly (a week noted), and the outfit handles permitting and inspections in-house. Pricing lands as fair and competitive. Follow-up visits at no cost have resolved lingering concerns. All 136 reviews rate five stars, with no one-star complaints recorded.
Fairfield Roofing
Sal answers calls himself and arrives quickly, often same-day or next-morning, especially for storm damage. Reviewers consistently praise fair pricing, expert diagnostics that avoid unnecessary replacement, and polished workmanship where repairs blend invisibly into existing roofs. Long-term customers report satisfaction with replacements and reliable follow-up when issues arise years later.
Which should you pick?
Pick R&A Remodeling & Roofing if
- You want in-house permitting and inspections handled without hiring a separate crew
- You want photo documentation and daily updates while emergency repairs are underway
- You want a contractor with a large, unblemished review history for a big-ticket job like a full replacement
Pick Fairfield Roofing if
- You want the owner himself on the phone and on the roof, not a dispatcher
- You're dealing with storm damage and want same-day or next-morning response without over-scoping the fix
- You'd rather get an honest repair estimate first and only replace if it's truly necessary
Verdict
The right call here comes down to how you want the emergency handled, not which score is higher. If you want a team that documents everything, handles permits, and has a flawless track record across a larger volume of jobs, R&A Remodeling & Roofing fits. If you'd rather have the owner himself answer the phone, show up fast for storm damage, and give you a repair-first fix instead of a replacement pitch, Fairfield Roofing is the better match.
Need help choosing a contractor?
Describe the job once and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Connecticut.
Enquiries you submit through this site's forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published scoring method and are not influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which one responds faster in a storm?
- Both are described as fast. Fairfield Roofing highlights same-day or next-morning response specifically for storm damage with the owner dispatching directly, while R&A's reviewers describe rapid turnarounds including a one-day fix after heavy rain.
- Which is better if I need a full roof replacement, not just a repair?
- R&A Remodeling & Roofing is the stronger fit, since it handles permitting and inspections in-house and has a larger volume of five-star reviews covering full replacements.
- Which is better if I just need a leak patched without being upsold?
- Fairfield Roofing's reviewers specifically praise its repair-first approach that avoids unnecessary replacement, which suits a targeted emergency patch.
- Does either offer true 24/7 availability?
- Neither summary states 24/7 hours explicitly. Fairfield Roofing calls out weekend and holiday emergency response, while R&A's fast response is documented through reviewer experiences rather than a stated schedule.