Best roofing contractors in West Haven

★★★★★4.9 (72 reviews)score 89/100

Tamay Enterprises posts the strongest composite score on this list, built on 72 reviews averaging 4.9 stars, with named techs Carlos, Thomas, and Segundo praised repeatedly for punctuality and clean work. The catch: nearly all of that review history is about furniture assembly, drywall, and general handyman jobs rather than roofing, so treat the roofing side of their business as unproven by this record.

• Large, high-volume review base (72 reviews)
• Named technicians with a consistent track record
• Punctual, communicative, and reasonably priced
• Serves West Haven, Orange, Milford, and New Haven

Watch out: Reviews center on furniture assembly and handyman work, not roof repair, so ask directly about roofing experience before booking.

Services: roof repair

★★★★★4.8 (49 reviews)score 85/100

Solid Rock Roofing earns consistent praise across 49 reviews for detail-oriented work on both residential and commercial roofs, with Mikey and his crew singled out for daily updates and jobsites left meticulously clean. They stand out for drone-assisted inspections and fast turnarounds on complex flat roof replacements, quoted competitively and without upsell pressure.

• Drone inspections for detailed reports
• Fast turnaround on flat roof replacements
• Daily communication during the job
• Competitive, no-pressure pricing

Services: flat roofing commercial, metal roofing, roof repair

★★★★★4.8 (76 reviews)score 85/100

Salinas Roofing has the deepest review base on this list at 76 reviews and a reputation for turning jobs around within 24 hours of a call. Manny and his crew are consistently credited with catching rot and water damage other contractors miss, and customers report zero leaks after storms, though one no-show appointment shows up as an outlier.

• Next-day service on many jobs
• Owner Manny hands-on and communicative
• Fair, competitive pricing
• Catches hidden rot and water damage

Watch out: One reviewer reported a missed appointment, an isolated incident against an otherwise strong record.

Services: flat roofing commercial, roof repair, roof inspection insurance, gutter services

★★★★★5 (10 reviews)score 76/100

About Time Home Improvement has a perfect 5.0 rating, though it's built on just 10 reviews so treat it as an early but promising signal. Reviewers highlight Mike and Dan Perry coming in as the lowest bidder among competing quotes and successfully managing an insurance claim covering roof, siding, gutters, and windows after storm damage.

• Often the lowest quote among competitors
• Direct owner involvement (Mike and Dan Perry)
• Insurance claim experience
• On-time, on-budget delivery

Watch out: Based on only 10 reviews, so the track record is thinner than the top-rated names on this list.

Services: metal roofing, roof replacement installation, roof inspection insurance, gutter services

★★★★★5 (12 reviews)score 71/100

Kohler Roofing Solar & Construction holds a perfect 5.0 across all 12 Google reviews, with Gary and his crew praised for fast turnarounds, including at least one roof finished in a single day. Multiple reviewers specifically credit the team with insurance claim navigation, with one customer paying nothing out of pocket after their help.

• Perfect 5-star review record
• Same-day roof completions reported
• Strong insurance claim navigation
• Organized, thorough cleanup

Watch out: Only 12 reviews on record, so confidence is lower than the higher-volume names above.

Services: roof repair, roof replacement installation, gutter services

★★★★☆3.9 (16 reviews)score 67/100

Connecticut Roofcrafters draws praise from satisfied customers for Michael's problem-solving on complex installs, including metal and cedar roofs that fewer contractors take on. The rating sits lower at 3.9 from 16 reviews because of documented slow response to initial inquiries and at least one warranty issue that wasn't fully resolved.

• Handles specialized metal and cedar roofing
• Clean, efficient crews on complex jobs
• Michael personally engages on tricky installs
• Long track record of repeat customers

Watch out: Some reviewers report slow initial response and a warranty repair that didn't fully fix a leak.

Services: roof repair, metal roofing, roof replacement installation

★★★★★4.9 (12 reviews)score 66/100

Quality Roofing Services focuses on commercial-scale work, including occupied multifamily buildings, downtown high-rises, and large flat roofs requiring mechanical coordination. Reviewers describe a team that consistently delivers on time and beyond scope, backed by millions of dollars in repeat client work, though the sample here is only 12 reviews.

• Commercial EPDM and flat roof expertise
• Manages occupied-building projects
• Long-term repeat commercial clients
• Consistently meets or exceeds project scope

Watch out: Review count is modest (12) relative to its commercial project scale, so newer residential customers have less to go on.

Services: roof inspection insurance, flat roofing commercial, roof repair, metal roofing

★★★★★4.6 (20 reviews)score 64/100

Colonial Exteriors performs well on standalone home roof and gutter jobs, with owner Chris known for following up personally and crews that clean thoroughly, even sweeping for stray nails. That said, a documented multi-unit project ran into months of delays and sporadic worker presence, so this pick is best suited to single-property jobs rather than larger builds.

• Owner Chris personally checks finished work
• Fast completion on single-home projects
• Thorough cleanup including nail sweeps

Watch out: A larger multi-unit job saw serious delays and incomplete work, so scope carefully before committing to bigger projects.

Services: flat roofing commercial, metal roofing, gutter services

★★★★☆3.7 (3 reviews)score 63/100

Franklin Custom Copperworks specializes in copper and custom roof work, with two five-star reviews praising attention to detail, clear communication, and quality materials delivered on schedule. The sample is very small at just 3 reviews, and one review broke from the positive pattern, so treat this as a promising but lightly documented option.

• Copper and custom roofing specialty
• Detail-oriented workmanship

Watch out: Only 3 reviews total, and one diverges from the otherwise positive feedback.

Services: metal roofing, gutter services

★★★★★5 (3 reviews)score 61/100

Nations Roof holds a perfect 5.0 across its 3 reviews, with feedback pointing to responsive, professional service and emergency availability. It's a bigger operation with FM Global approvals and manufacturer certifications, serving West Haven and greater New Haven, though the review count here is too small to draw strong conclusions.

• 24/7 emergency availability
• FM Global Approvals

Watch out: Only 3 reviews on file, so there's limited detail behind the perfect rating.

Services: roof repair, metal roofing

★★★★☆3.5 (8 reviews)score 51/100

G Salvati Roofing & Home Improvement gets five-star praise from some customers for solid roofing and siding work with fair initial quotes and clean sites, led by owner George Salvati. But that's balanced by one-star reviews citing repeated flashing problems and price increases after the fact, so the experience appears to vary by job.

• Owner George Salvati involved in assessments
• Thorough site cleanup after projects

Watch out: Some customers report flashing repairs needing multiple attempts and unexpected cost increases.

Services: roof repair, flat roofing commercial, gutter services

★★★☆☆3 (2 reviews)score 49/100

Beacon Roofing Company appears on this list with only 2 reviews on record, which isn't enough to establish a reliable pattern of service quality one way or the other. Worth a direct conversation before booking rather than relying on review history alone.

• Listed roofing contractor in the West Haven area

Watch out: Only 2 reviews available, so there isn't enough feedback yet to judge consistency.

Services: roof repair, metal roofing

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 46/100

Standing Seam Roofing's name points to a metal roofing focus, but with just 1 review on record there isn't enough history yet to say much about typical customer experience. It's included here for completeness rather than a proven track record.

• Single available review rated 5 stars

Watch out: Only 1 review on record, far too little to judge reliability.

Services: metal roofing, roof replacement installation

score 26/100

American Roofing Company has no Google reviews on file yet, so there's no customer feedback to evaluate. It's listed here for completeness as a roofing contractor operating in the West Haven area.

• Listed roofing contractor in the West Haven area

Watch out: No reviews on record yet, so there's no customer feedback to go on.

Services: roof repair

score 26/100

SLM Solution LLC has no Google reviews on file yet, so there's no track record to assess. It rounds out this list as a roofing option in West Haven worth a direct inquiry rather than review-based confidence.

• Listed roofing contractor in the West Haven area

Watch out: No reviews on record yet, so there's no customer feedback to go on.

Services: metal roofing, gutter services