Roofing contractor in Mystic

Roofing contractors serving Mystic, Connecticut. 16 providers available with local and nearby options. Average rating 4.7 stars.

Sixteen roofing contractors serve Mystic, with two based locally. The nearest option sits just 0.4 km away, and most operators in the area average 4.7 stars on Google. Top-rated choices include RSR Residential, Advanced Construction, and SERVPRO of New London.

Providers serving: 16
Avg rating: 4.7★
Nearest provider: 0.4 km
Based in Mystic: 2

Top-scored roofing contractors serving Mystic

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to Mystic. How we score ›

RSR Residential

5.0(53)✓ Google-verified

Every recent review is five stars. Customers say RSR undercuts bigger competitors by thousands of dollars while delivering skilled installation, often in one day, with crews who genuinely care about protecting landscaping and finishing spotless. Tom, Rob, and John handle estimates and project management with transparency and quick turnaround; the labor teams work in sync and clean up before leaving. One customer noted a delay in post-job warranty follow-up, but it's rare and minor against the consistent praise for fair pricing, warranty backing, and professional courtesy.

Roof RepairGutters & SidingRoof Inspection & Insurance Claims

View profile

Advanced Construction

4.4(50)✓ Google-verified

Advanced Construction shines on visible exterior work and siding projects, with crews praised for speed, cleanliness, and communication once work begins. David Preka and his team earn consistent five-star marks for deck replacement, historic restoration, and additions completed on schedule. However, a vocal minority reports serious gaps: material delays before jobs start, improper flashing and waterproofing that causes water damage later, and failure to disclose rotted wood to keep estimates low. One reviewer found fresh damage over old damage from prior Advanced work. Phone contact can be rough; at least one caller reported a dismissive receptionist. On smaller tasks (screen doors, railings), the crew sometimes goes silent. The 80% five-star rating masks a sharp divide: customers love the finished product and team professionalism on major projects, but some feel misled during the sales and inspection phases. Their website lists extensive licenses and a three-decade operating history, though reviews speak mainly to exterior and structural work rather than the full menu they advertise.

Roof RepairGutters & SidingRoof Replacement & Installation

View profile

SERVPRO of New London

5.0(27)✓ Google-verified

Fast emergency response with named technicians handling projects from start to finish. Team manages insurance claims, coordinates multi-week restorations with frequent updates, and restores homes to pristine condition. Staff accommodate customer schedules and wait for arrivals. Reviews emphasize water damage and mold remediation more than roofing.

24/7 Emergency RoofingRoof Inspection & Insurance ClaimsFlat & Commercial Roofing

View profile

AM PM Roofing

4.7(72)✓ Google-verified

AM PM Roofing completes most jobs in a single day with Paul leading hands-on inspections and fair pricing. Reviewers consistently praise the crew's efficiency, cleanup, and responsiveness, though two older complaints note a no-show appointment and unresolved siding staining after a roof replacement.

Roof RepairFlat & Commercial RoofingGutters & Siding

View profile

77 low data

SJM Roofing

4.6(30)✓ Google-verified

Clear explanations from Shaun, punctual crews, and thorough cleanup earn consistent praise in visible reviews. Averaging 4.6 stars on 30 reviews; negative reviews (about 10% of total) are not shown here.

Roof RepairGutters & SidingRoof Inspection & Insurance Claims

View profile

61 low data

Advanced Construction

4.8(4)✓ Google-verified

One reviewer praised the team for professionalism and speed on a roof repair. Evidence is limited to a single review, but the 4.8 rating across four Google reviews suggests consistent positive experience.

Roof RepairRoof Replacement & InstallationGutters & Siding

View profile

60 low data

Ivy Roofing Subcontractor

5.0(23)

Data mismatch: provided reviews are for Charm City Mold Inspections (Baltimore-area mold testing and remediation), not roof repair services. No review evidence for this business's actual roofing work.

Roof RepairGutters & SidingFlat & Commercial Roofing

View profile

67 low data

T.J. Nelson Home Improvements

5.0(13)✓ Google-verified

Five-star rated across 13 Google reviews for reliability, fair pricing, and consistent workmanship. No critical feedback available for perspective.

Roof RepairGutters & SidingRoof Replacement & Installation

View profile

61 low data

DC Property Management and Maintenance

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Reviews consistently praise on-time completion and fair pricing with quality work. Owner Daryl responds promptly to issues. Limited evidence (3 Google reviews, all 5-star, all from 3 years ago).

Roof Replacement & InstallationFlat & Commercial RoofingRoof Repair

View profile

JS and R Roofing LLC | Roofing Company | Roofer | Siding | Gutters

#10

77 low data

JS and R Roofing LLC | Roofing Company | Roofer | Siding | Gutters

4.9(38)✓ Google-verified

Customers consistently report same-day or rapid roof completion, careful site cleanup, and straightforward pricing. Jarod (owner) and crew handle residential reshingles and repairs across eastern Connecticut with attention to landscaping protection and debris removal.

Gutters & SidingRoof RepairFlat & Commercial Roofing

View profile

#11

JS and R Roofing Company | Roofer | Siding | Gutters Contractor

4.8(53)✓ Google-verified

Jarod and his team deliver roof and siding work in a single day with careful attention to site cleanliness and customer concerns. Reviewers consistently credit competitive pricing, transparent communication, and crew efficiency; the owner personally walks through quotes and stands behind his work with no pressure to upsell.

Gutters & SidingRoof RepairRoof Replacement & Installation

View profile

#12

56 low data

James Salls Roofing

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

One five-star review on file. Their website lists 20+ years in business and claims A+ BBB rating. Services span roof repair, replacement, installation, storm damage, gutters, siding, and more across Norwich and nearby towns. Limited review evidence.

Roof RepairRoof Replacement & InstallationFlat & Commercial Roofing

View profile

When you submit an enquiry through our forms, we may share it with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores come from our published scoring method only and are not affected by referral fees.